The Problem with Verbal Affirmations

February 4, 2010 · 16 comments

Verbal affirmations have been a popular topic involving goal-setting. Language is the most proactive form of communication and people nowadays believe that if you say something enough times, eventually you will condition your mind believe it. The essence of verbal affirmations involves setting a aside a period of the day, say 5 to 10 minutes, reaffirming a goal you have in mind as if it has already happened, and soon your mind will start to adopt belief, making it easier to reach the goal.

But the problem with this method is that aside from this period of time, we are constantly bombarded with other collective thoughts that conflict with our verbal affirmations.

Instead of forcing words out of the mouth to have power, it may be easier to change our external situation so that we are constantly bombarded with affirmations congruent to our goal. This is partially why advertisements make millions of dollars off of people. It works because they surround us everywhere. You can use this modeling the process to your advantage though.

Let’s take a very common example of losing weight. What you can do with verbal affirmations is tell yourself, “I have lost 5 pounds. I have lost 5 pounds. I have lost 5 pounds.” Depending on how strong you affirm these messages, for a brief moment in time, your mind will start to believe that you will have really lost 5 pounds. But there is also a good chance that after you say this and feel good about it, you find yourself walking to the nearest cabinet to eat a bowl of Fruit Loops.

Although you may have said that you have lost 5 pounds, your mind still can be affected by other things that may tell you otherwise. And you’ll constantly find yourself battling between your words and your actions. Verbal affirmations can help, but only to a degree. There are some more effective ways to your goal by conditioning other areas of your day, such as the people you hang out with, the environment you normally stay in, and the body language that you use.

People

Let’s go back to the example of losing weight. If you were a person that was obese, then it might not be the best idea to hang out with other obese people. By doing so, your mind will start telling itself that it’s okay to be obese. When you’re feeling down, you might even get support from others saying stuff like, “Don’t push yourself so hard” or “It’s okay to eat this sometimes; everybody’s human and needs a break.” These are affirmations from people telling you things that would contradict the goal of losing weight, but you would be unconscious of this because what they’re telling you makes you feel good about yourself.

In contrast, if you were a person who is obese, although it may feel uncomfortable, it would be a better idea to hang out with people who are fit (ideally people who are fit and positive). When you’re around them, you will probably get statements like, “Instead of eating this, try this” or “These exercises really help burn calories; you should try them out.” The mere presence of these people along with their support will reaffirm in your mind that this is what you want to look like and will encourage you to take action related to your goal.

Environment

Your environment plays a huge role in how your mind works. If you look around your environment, it may be a representation of your beliefs. Let’s go back to the example of losing weight. Imagine a place where the kitchen counter has stocks of white bread and chips. The inside of the refrigerator has peanut butter, jelly, salsa, butter, and Coke-Cola. The freezer is filled with at least a dozen boxes of microwavable food. This would be a very hard place to lose weight because the environment is telling you, “Eat me.”

Now imagine a kitchen counter with only tangerines. You open the refrigerator and you see bottles of water. Your house consists of tangerines and water. Although this is a slight exaggeration, you wouldn’t even need to verbally give yourself affirmations because the environment is providing it for you already. You would start to lose weight unconsciously.

Body Language

Although there are many other factors that can help affirmations, the last one I’m going to talk about here your body. You’re body language is often a measurement of what you believe. Even the smallest things sometimes matter. For example, how would the body affect an obese person? Well, if a person were to really take the goal seriously, they wouldn’t lie around the coach. They wouldn’t slouch because this can represent a negative attitude. Instead, act as if you were fit.

So the second question is what does a fit person look like? If you’ve ever seen a fit person walk in public, most people don’t walk with lazy or slouching posture. They like to show off their body. They walk straight. They hold their head with confidence. They smile because they are proud of their accomplishments. All of these things from their body language represent who they are inside.

Maybe you’re a person who has read a pop-psychology book that hypes up the importance of verbal affirmations by reading them aloud to yourself every day. Realize that the only way to really test out whether you are truly serious about achieving a goal in mind is to test your beliefs. Verbal affirmations is probably one of the the least effective ways to do this because they are often overridden by other areas that affect your life such as the people you normally hang out with, the environment that you stay in, and the body language that you put out. Change as many factors that you can think of that give you affirmations of what you want to achieve or who you want to be, and you’ll have an a lot easier time naturally developing a belief that, in the end, helps you get there.

Photo Credit: BozDoz

{ 16 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Ms. Freeman@Baby Steps of an Internet Entrepreneur February 5, 2010 at 8:35 am

It like your blog tag line, I’m starting from the middle of life. I am also implementing an environment change so that I can achieve my online goals.

Although verbal affirmation works in some cases, like you said changes in other areas need to occur as well in order for one to see their goals come to fruition.

Reply

2 Hulbert Lee February 5, 2010 at 1:32 pm

Good luck with your environmental change Ms. Freeman. I hope you end up achieving your online goals. :)

Reply

3 Dan @ Anxiety Support Network February 6, 2010 at 2:35 pm

Affirmations, like you have noted Hulbert, are only a small part of the total plan. I think that what most people who champion affirmations believe is that changing the mind is the most important and powerful of change, but that the other changes – environmental and body language – can be important changes to make as well. Good point that you raised!

Reply

4 Hulbert Lee February 6, 2010 at 11:15 pm

Exactly, like you say, ultimately it comes down to changing the mind and its beliefs. However one wants to do this is up to them and there’s no one right way to do this. Thanks Dan.

Reply

5 Steven | The Emotion Machine February 7, 2010 at 7:11 am

Very good post, although I have a couple nitpicks. First, affirmations don’t work by deluding ourselves that we have accomplished something in-which we haven’t. “I have lost five pounds” is not an affirmation…it should be something like, “I will lose five pounds.” Affirmations are a declaration of our goals not a substitute for achieving them.

Secondly, affirmations (also known as auto-suggestion) are most effective when we are in a particular focused and concentrated state of mind. It is like self-hypnosis, but you need to create that suggestible state in order for the affirmation to take hold.

BUT – to the point of your post – you are a hundred percent correct that the people we hang out with, the environment we are in, and our own body language ALSO send us implicit suggestions. If we are obese and hang out with other obese people (like your example) we MAY be implicitly saying, “It is okay to be obese.” or even, “At least I am not as bad as Tommy.”

So I definitely agree that there are limitations to verbal affirmations, and we need to be mindful of the suggestions we give ourselves throughout our daily habits. Very, very good post!

Reply

6 Hulbert Lee February 7, 2010 at 11:29 am

Thanks Steven, I also like what you said here. It makes a lot of sense that for verbal affirmations to work, one needs to be in a state of focus and concentration, rather than just saying it. Emotion should be involved, and part of that deals with being aware of the suggestions that we give to ourselves throughout the day.

Reply

7 King Sidharth February 8, 2010 at 9:51 am

Oops! I mean no offense but the universe and the laws and the science behind the working of affirmations is literal. Your sub-conscious mind accepts and materializes it as it is.
So I will loose weigh will always be ‘I will’ never ‘I’ve’.

@Hulbert:
Affirmations v/s reality that’s the show we are running and it is not a fight. Because what you tell yourself is always more powerful then outer condition. I am sorry to say but if you will try to control outer conditions you will have no success and affirmations have no meaning.

Affirmations create outer condition no vice-verse.
Life is not happening to you, you are creating your life with thoughts you are thinking right now and affirmations are there to change what you’ve been thinking since so long that now it feels natural and obvious. You’ve been thinking it so much that when you make a contradicting statement (affirmation) your mind says “LIAR!”

That’s the fight – inside outside is but a reflection of inside.

Reply

8 Hulbert Lee February 8, 2010 at 7:33 pm

Hi King. I agree that affirmations need to develop first from the inside of us, rather that trying to force them to happen from something outside. This shows when we are accustomed to being used to a habit we have, and then suddenly changing it with another affirmation that will usually be ineffective.

Reply

9 Chris Peterson February 8, 2010 at 4:26 am

I believe it has more to do with how the affirmation is played in our mind’s eye that causes it to work or not…that causes the thought to transform into action/creation or not.

If we are a domestic abuse survivor we will want to know this little secret about the proper way to use affirmations to regain our emotional well-being after an abusive relationship.

Reply

10 Hulbert Lee February 8, 2010 at 9:48 am

I agree Chris. Affirmations work better when they played out in the mind rather than verbally. Through our mind, it has a better chance to turn thoughts into action or creation like you mentioned here. Thank you.

Reply

11 Amit Sodha - The Power Of Choice February 8, 2010 at 9:22 am

Hey Hulbert,

There is a lot of power in repetitive thinking and as you said when powered by emotion, and not just an empty thought it does have the gusto to then send you into the right direction!

Great writing!

Reply

12 Hulbert Lee February 8, 2010 at 9:50 am

Haha I liked how you used the word gusto in here. Yes, emotions give our thoughts that extra push it needs to make them work. Thanks Amit.

Reply

13 King Sidharth February 8, 2010 at 9:52 am

Indeed emotions put so much more power to affirmations. Great Post – as always.

Reply

14 Hulbert Lee February 8, 2010 at 7:33 pm

Thanks King.

Reply

15 Raj@ The Positive Life April 26, 2010 at 11:54 am

As mentioned above, feeling the affirmations while speaking them is more important than just speaking them verbally.

Till the time, they are being emotionally felt, I believe there should be no problem with verbal affirmations.

Reply

16 Hulbert Lee April 26, 2010 at 7:32 pm

Thanks Raj. I was trying to emphasize in the post that feeling affirmations when you say them is more effective than just saying them and expecting them to work out.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: